And so this week’s moment of happiness despite the news.
I’m back.
And I don’t think I’ve ever been happier for a book in my life.
If you know me, you know words rule my existence. If I’m not writing them, I’m reading them, through published books and through the manuscripts of many, many students and clients. My classroom is full of books, and so is my home, which even has a shelf devoted to only my own books.
Soon after Michael’s accident, when he was still in the ICU, many people recommended that I read My Stroke Of Insight by Jill Bolte Taylor. I was resistant, but with so many people telling me to read it, I bought the book. It very quickly made me angry. Taylor’s experience was nothing like Michael’s. Yes, the stroke gave her a brain injury and she went through a lot. But she was home and walking and working on talking a week after her stroke. The only thing I found valuable in the book was a list at the end, that talked about how to behave and talk to someone with a brain injury.
After Michael died, many people recommended that I read Joan Didion’s book, The Year Of Magical Thinking. It’s about her experience with the first year after her husband’s death. I did buy it, and it’s on my To Read shelf. But I have not yet managed to open its covers. Sometimes, things just feel too close.
A few days ago, I finished reading a novel, Lit, by Tim Sandlin. I’ve had an incredible run of books lately, devouring all of them. Lessons In Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus. Wrecked by Catherine Newman. Some Bright Nowhere by Ann Packer. Heart The Lover by Lily King. And then Tim Sandlin’s book. Absolutely drunk on my recent deluge of incredible books, I sat in front of my To Read shelf and debated about what was next.
Bear in mind my To Read Shelf is actually two shelves. There’s a lot I want to read.
And I found a book I didn’t remember buying. The title was very intriguing, A Three Dog Life. It was a memoir. I pulled it out and read the jacket description.
“When Abigail Thomas’s husband, Rich, was hit by a car, his skull was shattered, his brain severely damaged.”
I put the book back. When did I buy this? Why did I buy this? No one recommended it to me…I must have found it on my own.
I pulled it back out. Turned to the first page. And then I read it cover to cover.
Nothing has come closer to my own experience. While Thomas’s husband lived for seven more years, most of it in a facility for Traumatic Brain Injury victims, there was so much that resonated. So much I recognized. And so very much that let me know that my reactions, my behaviors, my feelings during this whole damn time were normal and shared by others.
Thomas wrote about TBI patients going through a time of great rage and angry behavior. It’s normal in the period following the injury. No one told me that. I thought it was just Michael. I thought I was the only woman in the world who was scared at times of her gravely injured husband.
Thomas wrote about realizing that, some days, when her husband’s behavior was erratic and angry, it didn’t do her or him any good for her to remain in his room. So she walked out.
So did I. Many times. Often with him yelling at me to get out, to go away (often not knowing who I was), and his voice following me down the hospital hallway as I ran.
After several years passed for Thomas and her husband, she bought a house close to the facility where her husband lived. She adopted three dogs who she loved dearly. And as time went by, she found herself happy. Even though, she said, it was a life built on tragedy.
“And then one day I asked myself a terrible question. If I could make Rich’s accident never have happened, would I do it? Of course I would. Wouldn’t I? And instead of yes, I hesitated. But by posing the question, I had assumed the power, and by hesitating, I put myself behind the wheel of the car that struck my husband.
You want to talk about guilt?”
And then:
“BUT LOOK AT YOU, I STILL SAY TO MYSELF. HOW DARE YOU. You built this on tragedy.”
The capitalizations, by the way, are hers.
And I hugged that book to my chest as if Abigail Thomas was right there with me.
Her husband lived for seven years. Mine died after five months. But I can tell you that any time I find myself feeling happy, smiling, laughing, even just sitting in quiet contentment at home, an orange cat on my chest and an orange cat on my lap, the fireplace throwing light, my day’s work done, and the familiarity of the place I’ve lived for 20 years all around me…I then get walloped with the heaviest soakingest hardest wave of guilt.
Look at you, I think. How dare you. You are happy amidst tragedy.
Oh, it’s been hard. In so many ways, on so many levels.
And now, there was this book. And this person, this woman, Abigail Thomas. I wasn’t alone.
The relief that fell over me was easily as heavy as the guilt.
Did I take care of Michael well enough? Did I stand by his side, sit by his bed, long enough? Did I offer comfort and unconditional love, letting him know that I would be there, no matter the outcome? Even though the outcome became death?
Did I love Michael enough?
Yes. Yes, I did.
Words have saved me, over and over again, in my life. And words have saved me again.
Thank you, Abigail Thomas. I hope to meet you, and play with your dogs, and give you a real hug.
Maybe I’ll open Joan Didion’s book next.
And yes, that helps. Despite. Anyway.

































